Arguendo

Arguendo is the Core Project in the Lex Coterie Group of Organizations.

Thursday, 12 December 2013

Law School Myths:- Cracking Clat

Before you proceed reading further, let me tell you exactly what this is about. This is about all you people who made it to the NLU’s and also about all of those who didn’t. This isn’t a story about how amazing Law Universities are.  It’s about the people, not the places. Now that I have generated enough curiosity and confusion in your mind to be sure that you will read the entire thing before judging, let me begin.
So, you fought with the demon called CLAT and made it into a NLU? Good job! You must be on top of cloud 9, right? You must already be thinking how you’re the next CJI or maybe Salve. NEWS FLASH: - You are nothing right now. I am sorry, let me re-phrase it. You are nothing unless you prove otherwise. Let this sink in.
Now let me tell you why. And the reason is so simple after I am done explaining even you would admit that I am right. Getting into an NLU doesn’t make you great. Cracking CLAT doesn’t mean that you are the God of Law (Sorry folks, I know it might come as a shock to a few of you, but the tons you learn in your CLAT coaching classes, isn’t enough to even help you pass first year.) . I have met more people than I care to remember who cracked CLAT and made it to one of the top NLU’s without the slightest idea as to the difference between the Bar and the Bench. I refuse to go into a discussion as to how ‘difficult’ CLAT is (Anyone who has given CLAT or compared the different years papers would get my hint.). The point here is that, if you really think you are amazing just because you passed CLAT, you wouldn’t need college, would you?
Something similar needs to be noted by the so called non- NLU law students. Just cause you are not in the top law college of the country doesnt mean that you get the right to whine about the lack of opportunities. Yes, it might a a minor setback, but in the legal world if you are really good enough, you can always find opportunities for yourself. Being a student of a non-NLU student is not an excuse for not working hard enough to get opportunities. Ultimately it doesnt matter where you come from, what matters is where you intend to reach. If you try hard enough you will succeed. Never blame the situations for your failure, cause the situations are more often than not, a direct or indirect result of your own actions.

All NLU students kindly consider this, only 2-5 % of every batch to pass out of a Law School is considered its “cream.” But you might say, “Hey, what the hell? I am a NLU pass-out. I deserve to be picked by a Law firm before all the other riff-raff from other colleges.”  Being in a NLU doesn’t make you special or great. There are over a thousand of students passing out from all the different NLU’s all over India. At the best, a mere 50 law students would shine extraordinarily each year, maybe even less. And guess what, all those 50 students won’t be just from the NLUs. While it is true that there are more success stories in NLUs than other law schools, these credit for those success stories goes to the students alone.
A lot of students lose the potential they initially had when they make it to any college, that is when they let their ego and prides get into their head. The reason why NLISU, NALSAR, WBNUJS are deemed so highly even among NLUs, is not cause whoever makes it there is amazing. It is because these colleges shine, shape and give you all the opportunities that a student might need to outshine. But that doesn’t mean that you will shine. The colleges work is to shine. Whether you are a diamond or mere rock is for you to decide.
So let me summarize what I am going on about for all those who didn’t pick up the hint yet. Law colleges are amazing, but just because you are in one doesn’t mean you are amazing. Getting into a top law college doesn’t make you special. Surviving it does. Surviving doesn’t mean merely passing the 5 years. No, that would be called escaping. Surviving means understanding the complex, ever evolving world of law and adapting yourself to it. Look at it like this, Law is like a dangerous jungle safari. The colleges are those guides who instruct you on methods of survival in the wild. The top NLUs would be those experienced guides who would provide you with the latest high-tech resource. A new unknown college would mean you need to be more determined and put more effort than others in your line. But just because you have the resources at your disposal doesn’t guarantee their proper use, does it? This is where my point lies. How you use your resources depends on the individual. Any Law school can tell you what will be the best and the worst case scenario. They won’t help you when things turn bad in the real world. The fact is that in the long run it doesnt matter which law school you are from. It is you who should be special to begin with. Similarly, those not in NLU’s should sit and cry about the lack of opportunities. In Law School, there is nothing called lack of opportunities. NLU or not, if you are good enough, you will make it. In this respect Law is a lot like mathematics. You either understand it, or you don’t, you can’t be forced to learn it, irrespective of whether you are in NLUJ, GLC or SOL Christ University.
Out there in the real world, where you come from isn’t as important as what you can do. It is not about your college, it is about what you have done in that 5 year except just passing your subjects.


It should be noted that the writer has no problem whatsoever with NLU’s or other colleges. This writing is merely a satire. A dark humor aimed at Law students anywhere who initially deem themselves above rest of human race simply because we are in a Law School.  

Tuesday, 10 December 2013

The Shehzada, Mango Man and a Vikas Purush : A tale of election 2013

        To a country that has been a witness to umpteen elections, the winning or losing of a party is not an unusual phenomenon. The sphere of democracy has seen many stalwarts as well as new stars rise, fall and retain their power in the political setup of our country. But the one that has risen today whose win is a reflection of aspirations of people and the dissatisfaction is none other than Arvind Kejriwal, who was called an ‘ant’ by a congress minister. He has emerged to be the giant slayer who has reduced the grand old party to a mere third by defeating a veteran like Sheila Dixit giving a fitting reply to the existing parties that he is here to stay and that the process of shift has just begun. This is the story of a "mango man" and his party (Aam Aadmi Party) which evinces a striking fact that what is being sought by people is not free schemes but instead, good, clean and accountable governance where their mandate is respected.


       Defeats are normal in politics and there is absolutely no dishonour in losing a democratic election. Some defeats are tolerable, others are severe. Either way, it is how a party and its leaders respond to that defeat that defines their character. But the Shehzada doesn’t seem to have learnt anything from the crushing defeat in the UP election in 2012. The "escape velocity" for development and change cannot be attained by mere words but with conviction and actions. Tearing away one piece of legislation and giving free schemes by more legislations is not all what people are asking for, and it’s high time that the prince understands the fact that only "will power and confidence" doesn’t help one to overcome an election and discontent of people.  It’s time for the prince to step into reality and concede that the party in his leadership is a wreck and he needs to do more than just imagining of bringing about a change. This would be one birthday gift to the Congress President to see and accept that they are completely decimated in Rajasthan and Delhi and are helpless while BJP got a hattrick in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.


      Everything now points to the BJP emerging as the single largest party, by some distance in the coming Lok Sabha elections under the leadership of "Vikas Purush" i.e the man of development, Narendra Modi. Undoubtedly, the momentum is for BJP and it has to maintain and simultaneously consolidate its position. The job only gets tougher and tougher for Modi to sell his development model and ideas in a more effective way as Chattisgarh and Delhi tell us that there is no Modi wave to neutralise the local factors. The credit for the victory of Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan should be given to the stellar performance of Shivraj Singh Chauhan’s government which could triumph over the anti-incumbency wave and take the party to a third term in the state which has shown that Shivraj is a Modi in making.  Coming to Rajasthan, the fruitful results are an outcome of Raje's efficient portrayal of pathetic performance of Gehlot government that was labelled as a corrupt incompetent government. In the battle for India, Modi has to navigate his party through the minefields of Bihar and UP moving from the comfort of Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan. He has to play his cards safe with an array of regional satraps watching him to bet on the outcome at the right moment.



About The Author:-

    Manoj Reddy 
    3rd Year, BBA-LLB (Hons.)
    FOL, IFHE, Hyderabad.

LEGAL STARTUPS IN INDIA: LAW IN AN SOCIAL NETWROKING ERA - Part I

      In India, Law has always been regarded as a subject which drags you more into books. But, after the introduction of five year law courses this stream of education has taken a professional shift. The new curriculum has brought new innovations where law can be pursued within the traditional discipline and even beyond that. The experiments in the form of interdisciplinary law courses and recently, the introduction of legal studies by CBSE in the intermediate level have welcomed such products.
Law is equipped with co-curricular activities in which mooting is at the first place. Information about Moot Court competitions is available at different websites like Students at Law(http://studentatlaw.in/ ), Advocate Khoj ( http://www.advocatekhoj.com/ ), Law Mantra (http://lawmantra.org/  )  and Lawctopus (http://www.lawctopus.com/ ) . News about the happenings in the legal and the extra-legal world are available at websites like Live Law (http://www.livelaw.in/ ), Legally India (http://www.legallyindia.com/ ), Bar and Bench (http://www.barandbench.com/ ). Other activities which are a part of the Law School are MUNs, Parliamentary debates and the very recent Mock Parliaments and MUNs. Updates on these are also available on the mentioned websites.

Depicting the biased nature of the author here, I hereby return back to my story. When suddenly one day I navigated through the webpages of The Knowledge Steez (http://knowledgesteez.wordpress.com/ ), I found information regarding ‘Call for Papers’, Internships, workshops and Essay writing Competitions.  After several enquiries, I eventually landed up finding out what these things actually meant and what ‘The Knowledge Steez’ actually was. In the whole course of navigation, I came across websites like Conference Alert (http://conferencealerts.com/) and The Social Science Informer (http://thesocialscienceinformer.blogspot.com/). Information on Legal Internships is also available on Click Internship (http://clickinternship.wordpress.com/). Legal Trigger is again a player in the league(www.legaltrigger.com ).

Moreover, the solutions of these websites are available at Facebook groups like Law Students in India (https://www.facebook.com/groups/lawstudentsofindia/) and Legal Point (https://www.facebook.com/groups/legalpoint/ ). For the Sake of Argument (http://sbfsa.blogspot.in/ ) is also a takeoff. These are a few; and there are many more.

  The above article is a part of the Law In Social Networking Era Series. Please keep visiting for the next part of this article.

Author:-
Tejaswini Ranjan
2nd Year, CNLU

INDIAN MEDIA AND THE ALLIED DEBATES - Part I

Media is the fourth pillar of Indian democracy. It is a source of information, awareness and also, a mode creating sensational news. The visual and the apparent resources entrusted with media inevitably make media a responsible entity. Therefore, “ETHICS” to regulate media becomes very much important in a country like India where multiple societal faiths exist. Nowadays, most of the part of a newspapers front page is filled with advertisements; this clearly indicates that the idea to make more and more money is on ascendant.Also, media has continuously been publishing news which keeps it away from the informational and educational pursuit.

Now the interrogation which stands up is “Should Media be regulated?”. In the first overview, the answer ascends an affirmation but when we inspect the norms of Indian democracy, the idea is subject to negation. The Fundamental Rights enumerated in the Indian Constitution here play a judgmental role. On one side, these rights provide the ‘Freedom of Speech’ but on the other side, they restrict this freedom. This makes the regulation a subject to debate.

The recent arrest of two editors of a reputed news channel in relation to the “Paid News” on the Coalgate scam has also become pejorative. The arrest of the two girls on their updates on the death of a leader in India is again critical. The reporting guidelines for Media are a directive again; the question is how much is that justified. Moreover, media in India is not limited to the contemporary designation; it extends to social media as well. The pros and cons taking in account all the trends and types are to be discussed in furtherance of this debate.


 This is a part of the series of Analysis of Indian Media & Journalism. Please keep checking for the next part.

Author:-
Tejaswini Ranjan
2nd year, CNLU,